Review:
House of Salt and Sorrows
Author: Erin A. Craig
Publisher: Delacourt Press, 2019
Source: Personal Purchase
I am going to handle this review as though it were a panel discussion. The panel consists of the Brothers Grimm (BG), Edgar Allan Poe (EAP), and Daphne du Maurier (DdM) (just because Rebecca is one of my favorite gothic romances – but others could have filled this place, too). I (BW) get to be the moderator, and we are discussing just what makes House of Salt and Sorrows, a wonderfully macabre retelling of “The Twelve Dancing Princesses,” such a satisfying read.
BG: In our original story, the King issues a proclamation if anyone could discover the secret of why the princesses’ shoes were worn each morning, that person would be able to choose one as their wife and reign after his death. However, if the person failed to discover the secret, their life would be forfeit. Plenty of men tried and were shown no mercy when they failed. They lost their heads. The princesses cleverly drugged each would-be King and then went off to an enchanted land where they danced each night away. Then along came an old soldier who received some excellent advice (don’t drink the wine) and was given an invisibility cloak. He only pretended to fall asleep, followed the princesses under the invisibility cloak, and discovered their secret. He even brought back proof for the King. He was allowed to marry one of the princesses and rule the kingdom.
BW: This story also has twelve princesses, but it is actually quite different.
BG: Yes, that’s true. In this story, the princesses only think they are the clever ones. In truth, someone far more evil is in charge of their nightly attendance at the balls. And there is another significant difference. By the time their father actually announces his contest, four of the sisters have died and there are whispers that the Thaumas sisters are cursed. There is even the sense that at least the last death was not an accident.
EAP: Speaking of a truly evil characters, I don’t know if even I could have invented some of the horrors that Annaleigh (the princess from whose point of view the story is told) experiences. I mean, that final ball – punch that is actually hacked-up bits of fish floating in blood? Maggots spilling over a platter of a sea turtle and then flowing over Annaleigh’s body? Wow, this is really gory stuff!
BW: Erin A. Craig was obviously an admirer of your stories. She used the names of plenty of your most well-known characters: Morella, Ligeia, Lenore. There is even a character named after you. Edgar is the name of the murdered sister’s supposed suitor.
DdM: I like how Craig keeps you guessing about who is behind all this until the very end. Who can Annaleigh trust? Who can she go to about her suspicions? Her father is not at all sympathetic, but thinks she is causing trouble. Her stepmother just wants to ignore all the unpleasant deaths. Annaleigh isn’t able to go to her sisters – there is some really strange stuff going on with them and it’s obvious they can’t be taken into her confidence. The man, Edgar, who also believed her sister Eulalie was murdered, is also killed. It’s really hard for Annaleigh to know who to turn to. And then there is Cassius. Despite some very mysterious behavior on his part, Annaleigh longs to trust him. It’s really quite romantic.
BW: What about the ending? Did you find it satisfying?
DdM: Entirely so. To say more would be to give too much away.
EAP: It certainly has a more positive ending than my stories.
BG: The whole thing is more satisfying. There are far more details: the opulent balls, the beautiful dresses. Of course, there is more of the scary stuff, too: the ghostly visitations and, as Edgar mentioned, some real horror. We don’t shy away from harsh realities in our fairy tales, but these scenes are just so vivid.
BW: I think the panel and I would agree. This is a truly magical book, one you won’t want to miss (even if there are parts you wouldn’t want to be reading on a dark and stormy night).